Tuesday, October 22, 2019

The Life and Death of Wyatt Earp

Copyright 2019 by Gary L. Pullman


Wyatt Earp

Obituaries. I never read them when I was younger. I don't read many of them now. Anyone who does, though, soon realizes what an odd, rather grotesque type of essay they are, part biography and part eulogy.

Most death notices also provide a handy, if not dandy, summary of the times in which the dearly departed lived. (In obituaries, almost all of the departed are “dear,” regardless of the what they may or may not have done during their lifetimes.)

Wyatt Earp's obituary.

The Internet Archives website stores the Los Angeles Times's January 14, 1929, obituary of Wyatt Earp. The death notice's headline reads, “Tamer of Wild West Dies.” The piece's subtitle offers a tad more information, even as it further characterizes the decedent: “Wyatt Earp, Picturesque Gun-Fighting Marshal of Frontier Days, Passes Without Boots On.”

Wild Bill Hickok

The article begins with name-dropping, as its anonymous author reminds the newspaper's readers that Earp was friends and “colleagues” with the likes of “Wild Bill” Hickok, Bill Tilghman, Ben Thompson, and “Bat” Masterson. (No mention is made of Earp's greatest friend and colleague, Doc Holliday.

Some of the information the obituary reports isn't altogether reliable. Earp may have met Hickok, but the marshal of Abilene, Kansas, wasn't a “friend” of Earp's, and, although Earp knew Thompson on a casual basis, the outlaw was far from one of Earp's pals.


Shootout at the OK Corral.

The obituary notes that Earp helped to bring “law and order into the rough cow camps of the West with .45-caliber bullets.” While it's true that Earp did exchange bullets with his adversaries in the Shootout at the OK Corral and during the equally famous vendetta ride that followed this event, he more often buffaloed his adversaries than shot them. However, it seems that the Times author wanted to sell his readers on the image of Earp as a “picturesque” figure; to do so, he apparently thought it necessary to exaggerate the facts a bit.


Doc Holliday

In mentioning the OK Corral gunfight, the writer makes no mention of Holliday, although the other participants are named. Perhaps the author supposed that a mention of Hickok would detract from the luster of Earp or would tarnish the carefully contrived image of the deceased that the author appears to have labored to depict.


Josephine ("Sadie") Earp

Another possibility might be that allusions to Holliday were omitted in deference to Earp's widow, who took pains to preserve a pristine, rather than a picturesque, view of her late husband. References to his association with a drunken, boozing gambler and gunfighter whose common-law wife had been (like Earp's own second wife) a prostitute might not fit with the idea that Earp was a heroic lawman who helped to “tame” the Wild West.

Bob Fitzsimmons (left) and Tom Starkey

Other of Earp's endeavors are cited, including his prospecting for gold in the Klondike; his controversial refereeing of the Fitzsimmons-Starkey boxing match in Oakland, California; his taming of Colton, California; and his management of the copper mine and “four oil wells . . . near Bakersfield,” California, that he owned and his “breeding of horses.”

As much a jack-of-all-trades in his advanced years as he'd been in his prime, Earp also offered “technical advice” to early Hollywood filmmakers concerning “their productions.”


William S. Hart

At the end of the obituary, the writer again drops a few names: actor “Bill” Hart, movie producer Wilson Mizner, boxing promoter Tex Rickard, Earp's widow Josephine (“Sadie”) Earp, and his sister Mrs. W. Edwards. Earp's “honorary pallbearers,” readers learn, included Hart and Mizner.


Milton Mizner


Tex Rickard

No comments:

Post a Comment

Confessions of an Armchair Traveler and Historian

 Copyright 2023 by Gary L. Pullman My Aunt Ruby Messenger wrote a book, Faith and the Edge of Danger , chronicling her missionary service in...